Unpaid work by women

What is the true impact on their mental health?

| THE INDEPENDENT | Over the last several decades, gender roles have evolved and changed to reflect shifting societal norms. Yet, despite these changes, unpaid household labour disparities still exist between partnered men and women worldwide.

From cooking and cleaning, to fetching water and firewood or taking care of children, the elderly, and the sick, women carry out at least two and a half times more unpaid household and care work than men.

It is now recognised that women’s unpaid work subsidises the cost of care that sustains families, supports economies and often fills in for the lack of social services.

Unpaid care and domestic work is valued to be 10 and 39 per cent of the Gross Domestic Product and can contribute more to the economy than the manufacturing, commerce or transportation sectors, according to the ‘Women’s economic empowerment in the changing world of work’ Report of the Secretary-General, December 2016. Yet, it is rarely recognised as “work”.

In this Special Feature, we take an in-depth look at how this unequal division of unpaid work affects women’s mental health and relationships. We also spoke with three experts to gain insight into this global issue.

Although gender roles are less rigid than they were decades ago, data suggest that, in heterosexual relationships, the burden of unpaid work still falls on women — even in cohabitating relationships where both partners are employed.

For example, 2021 US Bureau of Labor Statistics data shows that both spouses were employed in 46.8% of married couple families. Yet statistics also indicate that 59% of women report doing more household work than their partners.

According to data from the Gender, Institutions and Development Database of the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD), the average number of hours per day spent on unpaid care work by women compared to men by regions of the world is highest in the Middle East and North Africa and South Asia and least in North America and Sub-Saharan Africa.

The amount of time men spend on household tasks has doubled since the mid-1970s, according to other data quoted in an article on the issue in Medical News Today. For instance, it says, in 1976, men spent around 6 hours a week on household duties. In 2005, that number increased to around 12.5 hours per week.

But, in those same years, women still spent more time completing unpaid household labor — specifically, around 26 hours per week in 1976 and around 16.5 hours per week in 2005.

The article titled ` What is the true impact of unpaid labor on women?’ says the impact unpaid labour inequities may have on women’s mental health is often overlooked.

It describes findings by scientists from the University of Melbourne, Melbourne, VIC, Australia, who investigated the relationship between unpaid labour and mental health among employed adults.

Their findings, published in The Lancet Public Health, suggest a negative association between unpaid labour and mental health for employed women. However, the researchers did not find the same associations for working men.

The impact of unpaid labor on mental health

To conduct the research, the scientists reviewed 19 studies with 70,310 total participants from across the globe. Qualifying studies were peer-reviewed and measured the amount of unpaid labor among employed adults. They also outlined associations between this type of work and self-reported mental health concerns, including depression and psychological distress.

After examining the research, the study authors found that women reported taking on more unpaid work regardless of geographical location and time setting. Moreover, this added burden was associated with poorer mental health in women. However, the impact on men was less clear.

In addition, the researchers also found that a 1-hour increase in unpaid work per week led to small but significant changes in mental health status. Furthermore, some studies in the review reported a 0.2–0.4-point rise in depression scores for every 10-hour increase in unpaid labor time.

Although more investigation is needed, the study authors suggest that persistent household labor inequities continue to exist among male and female partners worldwide. And this imbalance exposes women to an increased risk of negative mental health effects.

What constitutes unpaid labour?

Study author Jennifer Ervin, a doctoral researcher in the Centre for Health Equity at the Melbourne School of Population and Global Health, told Medical News Today: “There is no universally recognised term or definition for unpaid labour — also referred to as unpaid work, unpaid care work, domestic labour, or household labour — but it is considered broadly inclusive of all responsibilities and tasks done to maintain a household and its family members without any explicit monetary compensation.”

“So childcare is a big one, and relatedly so is care for people with disability, health conditions or who are elderly. But it also includes domestic work like laundry, food preparation, cleaning, running errands, and outdoor tasks,” she added.

Work inequities and mental health in women vs men

The study authors suggest that a significant unpaid workload combined with the responsibilities of employment may contribute to role overload, conflict, and time scarcity, which can negatively affect mental health.

Additionally, housework is often perceived as mundane, undervalued, or unenjoyable.

However, men may experience less adverse mental health concerns with unpaid labour because of the nature of the tasks.

Ervin explained:  “We know that men commonly do the less time-sensitive jobs within the household, such as outdoor or maintenance tasks. These are referred to in the literature as high-schedule-control tasks — as one has more control over when one undertakes this type of unpaid labor work.”

To clarify further, Ervin said that “a good example is that you can delay mowing the lawn until the weekend, for instance, when you are less time-pressured, whereas you cannot delay feeding a hungry child or driving a dependent to a medical appointment.”

“Outdoor tasks are also theorised to not only be less time-sensitive but may also be more enjoyable and possibly protective than other types of household work,” she added.

Dr. Naomi Murphy, consultant clinical and forensic psychologist and co-founder of Octopus Psychology, told MNT: “Inequality causes anxiety and depression. It creates distance between unequal parties and causes mistrust and resentment. […] It can leave women feeling devalued and resentful of their partner and overwhelmed by the volume of responsibilities they have.”

She also noted that the unequal burden “can lead to feelings of isolation and loneliness within the relationship.”

“If significantly more of the responsibility is shouldered by one person, it can create a sense of overwhelm and a feeling that you can’t meet all your responsibilities; it can also lead to a reduction in confidence,” Dr. Murphy explained.

Getting to the root of unpaid labor inequities

Household labour disparities between men and women may have resulted from several factors. Ervin suggests that it may be “substantially rooted in historical context and times — when it was normative for women to be homemakers and for men to be breadwinners.”

“Resultantly, there remain deeply entrenched gender roles and social norms around the gendered division of household labor. Unfortunately, despite women entering the paid workforce in unprecedented numbers during the 20th century, there has not been a parallel or remotely equal increase in men’s participation in labor on the home front,” Ervin explained.

Dr. Murphy further noted the intergenerational impact of unpaid labor inequities:

“Families often socialise daughters into helping more with household chores; generations of women have done this, so the patterns are entrenched. As girls are more likely to emulate their female role models, this pattern gets transferred from one generation to the next.”

The broader impact of unpaid labor

In addition to mental health harm, ongoing unpaid work inequities may impact personal and professional relationships.

According to Dr. Mark Goulston, psychiatrist and executive coach, and founding member at Newsweek Expert Forum, unpaid labour imbalances “can cause women to feel more overwhelmed, [to] often feel […] that at any moment they are disappointing someone so that if they’re focused on work, they’re neglecting home and children and if they’re focused on home and children, they’re neglecting work.”

He also noted that “women who are exhausted can become impatient with their children and inside feel deep resentment which can cause them to feel shame and that they are an awful mother.”

According to Dr. Murphy, “the loss of confidence created by overwhelm can [also] spill out to professional life.”

Moreover, “the person shouldering the burden of household work may feel anger at their partner for not pulling his weight which can translate into intimacy problems,” she added.

Coping strategies

To facilitate changes when experiencing unequal division of household work, Dr. Murphy offered the following suggestions to women: talk with your partner and tell them how you feel before the issue becomes problematic, discuss and negotiate a fair division of labour, find ways to appreciate each other and remind yourself why you fell in love, find ways to value yourself and appreciate yourself, and    consider couples counseling to rekindle closeness, intimacy, and improve communication.

“Try not to criticise how your partner does the contributions they do make – they may not be doing it as fast as you like or in the same way, but criticism is likely to deter them from contributing,” she also advised.

On a larger scale, changing deeply rooted unpaid labour inequities within families may require specific policy changes.

Moving forward, Ervin suggested that “[p]olicies such as universal childcare and normalising flexible working arrangements and extended paternity leave for men can help in shifting the dial and driving greater gender equality in the division of unpaid labor and unpaid care.”

“Importantly, however, we need to be careful about policies that only target women as this may reinforce gender inequalities,” she emphasised.

She said: “We need to dismantle norms around what it means to be an ideal worker and highlight the importance of gender-neutral approaches to leave and flexible working – accommodating how work integrates with home life for both women and men. This is fundamental to gender equality.”

****

MNT story was by Kimberly Drake